Genetic heritage

Those of you who have followed this blog since its inception may remember a post which described the sale of our herd of American Milking Devon cattle last September. If we had kept our Devons we would have celebrated the decennial anniversary of having them here on the farm in just two months. The decision to raise Milking Devons, the status of which has been classified as critical by the American Livestock Breeds Conservancy, was motivated by our desire to do our part to preserve rare and heritage breeds of livestock. One unfortunate aspect of commercial livestock farming in the twenty-first century is that the preservation of species diversity is not the focus of many breeding programs. The practice of artificial selection may improve any number of physical and physiological characteristics of both plants and animals. Indeed, selective breeding alone is responsible for the improvement of today’s commercial plant and animal stocks over their not-so-ancient predecessors. Consider Teosinte and its domestication as Maize, for example. Artificial selection requires variation, without it populations cannot be modified. Without variation, natural populations cannot adapt to changing local environments. When this phenomenon occurs in nature we call it natural selection. Because most farmers have become myopically preoccupied by the efficiency of production, most are unaware of or ignore the importance of preserving genetic diversity. The Union of Concerned Scientists has written about this problem. The following points were taken from a piece, found at the website of that group, entitled Industrial Agriculture: Features and Policy.

  • U.S. agriculture rests on a narrow genetic base. At the beginning of the 1990s, only six varieties of corn accounted for 46 percent of the crop, nine varieties of wheat made up half of the wheat crop, and two types of peas made up 96 percent of the pea crop. More than half the world’s potato acreage is now planted to a single variety, the Russet Burbank.
  • Farmers have recognized for decades that the decline in genetic diversity in agriculture is a problem, but it has gotten worse rather than better over that period of time.
  • The pressures on farmers to grow uniform varieties come from many sources, seed companies, food processors, consumers, transporters, and the designers of farm machinery.
  • A decline in the genetic diversity in agriculture is important for a number of reasons. Crops that are very similar to each other in yield and appearance are also similar in their susceptibility to disease. In 1970, the Southern Corn Leaf Blight destroyed 60 percent of the U.S. corn crop in one summer, clearly demonstrating that a genetically uniform crop base is a disaster waiting to happen.
  • In addition, modern crop breeders rely on the broad varieties of crops developed over the centuries as sources of resistance traits. Plants that farmers or gardeners no longer grow are sometimes lost forever, taking with them genes for pest resistance and stress resistance that future farmers may desperately need.

Although these statements focus on plant crops, the very same may apply to animals stocks as well. Although there are more than 100 breeds of cattle in the United States only six typically populate our commercial dairies (Ayrshire, Brown Swiss, Guernsey, Jersey, Holstein, and Milking shorthorn). It is the genes in the bodies of individuals which make up the other 94 breeds which distinguish them from these six. The genes which comprise all 100 breeds form what is called the gene pool. It is this genetic reservoir which banks the species as a whole against disaster in the face of changing environmental circumstance. It is the mission the ALBC, and groups like it, to …  ensure the future of agriculture through the genetic conservation and promotion of endangered breeds of livestock and poultry. You can do your part in supporting plant and animal gene pools by purchasing meat, poultry, and vegetables from those you know to be raising heritage breeds. Small-holding farmers often raise rare breeds because they (the farmers) are less likely to be subject to the commercial pressures mentioned above. It may require more effort on your part to attend a Farmer’s Market (on Saturday morning, perhaps, when you’d prefer to be sleeping in) or to sign on as a member of CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) but if you do, you will know you are doing your part for the long-term survival of all of our important species of food plants and animals.

American Milking Devon heifer calf
Pairodox Grace DOB 10.18.09
(Ox Hill Garnet X Highland Hollow Duke of Devonshire)

7 thoughts on “Genetic heritage

  1. Well, yes I do remember this post and apparently commented on it 🙂 . Just thinking that you could expand on this by addressing some different seed diversity issues one post at a time. I can imagine a picture similar to your pumpkin photo but featuring corn… a lot of folks are not visually aware of the amazing diversity in tomatoes or cucumbers or beans, for example. Just saying!

  2. Well written … it will be interesting to see if this year’s drought sparks a national conversation regarding the risks of monoculture and the lack of genetic diversity in our crops and livestock.

    1. Excellent point. My guess is … no. Folks, in general, aren’t able to relate the two issues; drought and drop in production, and the genetics of hardy heritage breeds. If only …

  3. Well said. I endorse your sentiment whole-heartedly and we do our part on our farm to raise rare breed poultry. Of course, there are a few Red Star Layer Hens running around because I thought we should give them a try. Beautiful photo. Out of curiosity, are you missing your Devons? Thank you for another well-written article.

    1. Oh my … oh my … someone does understand. Yes, yes, yes I miss them … very much. Every time my eyes draw up the hill and I don’t see my cows I miss them. Even writing about it makes me sad. The decision to sell the herd was very, very difficult. Feed costs were getting out of hand and, to be honest, they were becoming just a bit much for us to handle … especially the steers and bulls. Life is full of very difficult decisions, isn’t it? The current owners of the herd have a website that I check periodically – I shouldn’t – it’s really not good for me. Thanks for your obvious understanding and kind observations. D

      1. 😦 Shoot, why do we do this to ourselves? Some people collect shoes … life could be so much simpler 🙂
        Thinking of you all on the upcoming decennial.

Respond to this post if you'd like.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s